Response to “Does Woodlands Checkpoint expansion need to be on such a grand scale?" (The Straits Times 31 January 2024)
The Straits Times
10 February 2024
Woodlands Checkpoint expansion essential to meet future traffic demands, evolving security needs
We refer to Mr Gerald Lee’s letter, “Does Woodlands Checkpoint expansion need to be on such a grand scale?” (Jan 31).
Today, the Woodlands Checkpoint (WCP) clears about 300,000 travellers per day – a significant increase from 230,000 in the year 2000 – and often exceeds this level during long weekends and holidays.
The number of travellers passing through WCP is projected to reach 400,000 per day by 2050.
Mr Lee suggested that the expansion of WCP must be made with “due consideration of all relevant factors”. The Immigration and Checkpoints Authority (ICA) had indeed considered all the relevant factors, including land size and design, that are needed to provide efficient immigration clearance for travellers for the long term, and to ensure robust border security.
Over the years, we have implemented several measures to increase clearance efficiency and throughput at WCP.
These include deploying officers dynamically depending on where manpower is needed, reconfiguring the clearance lanes depending on the traffic situation, and installing more automated lanes.
However, there is a limit to how much we can address congestion based on WCP’s current footprint – hence the need to expand.
ICA conducted extensive feasibility and technical studies to determine the optimal land size needed to ensure that the expanded WCP can meet projected future traffic demands and evolving security needs, while considering other factors such as impact on residents and traffic nearby.
For such a major infrastructure project, forward planning is critical to avoid the need for frequent adjustments down the road that can be disruptive to checkpoint operations and, ultimately, travellers.
ICA’s plan to redevelop WCP in phases over the next 10 to 15 years will ensure that we meet our intended aims.
With the envisaged size and design, the aim is to try and reduce the average travel time for vehicular traffic during peak periods from the current 60 minutes, though this of course depends on a range of factors, not all of which are predictable now.
If nothing is done, the travel time for vehicular traffic could increase by more than 60 to 70 per cent during peak periods by 2050.
The redeveloped WCP would also allow for more automated lanes, including for cars. This will reduce ICA’s manpower needs, which is a major and pressing constraint.
The additional space will provide adequate holding areas to contain traffic within the checkpoint, to reduce congestion spillover onto local roads.
Even as we expand WCP, ICA will continue to leverage technology and innovative solutions to enhance travellers’ clearance experience.
Patrick Ong
Head, Strategic Communications and Media Relations
Corporate Communications and Service Division
Immigration and Checkpoints Authority
<Original Letter>
The Straits Times
31 January 2024
Does Woodlands Checkpoint expansion need to be on such a grand scale?
I am flummoxed by the announcement that Woodlands Checkpoint will be expanded to five times its size (Woodlands Checkpoint expansion work to start in 2025, first phase to be completed by 2032, Jan 29).
A doubling or tripling of its operational capability would have been more realistic.
There are so many factors to be taken into account before this huge sum of money is spent on the project, including the completion of the Johor Bahru-Singapore rail link, and faster contactless clearance.
I agree there are improvements and adjustments to be made for faster Causeway clearance.
But decisions must be made with due consideration of all relevant factors.
We might not need improvements on such a grandiose scale, especially when there are periods of little activity at the checkpoint.
Gerald Lee